ProteinPan

East Oak vs Masterbuilt Electric Smoker: 30-Inch Comparison

East Oak vs Masterbuilt electric smoker: cooking space, smoke at low heat, controls, probes, app and owner-reported reliability for the 30-inch models.

By November 19, 202610 min readHow we research

Delicious grilled chicken served with vegetables, flatbread, and a variety of spices
Photo by Mustafa Erdağ on Pexels

As an Amazon Associate, ProteinPan earns from qualifying purchases. We never accept free products or payment for placement.

The short answer

  • EAST OAK wins on space and probes. Both EAST OAK 30-inch models list 725 sq in and a built-in meat probe, against 710-711 sq in for the Masterbuilts.
  • Masterbuilt wins on price tier and low-heat range. The standard 30-inch sits in the under-$300 tier, and the 710 WiFi lists 100-275°F, the only low setting listed here.
  • Smoke is the shared weakness. Owners of both brands report thin smoke below roughly 250-275°F, so plan to run hotter and add chips often.
  • Reliability complaints are common to both. Failed controllers show up in owner reports for each brand, so season the smoker early and keep the receipt.
On this page

If you are choosing between an EAST OAK and a Masterbuilt, the East Oak vs Masterbuilt electric smoker question comes down to three things: space, controls and how much smoke each makes at low heat. Both brands sell 30-inch digital models with a side chip loader, so the differences are small. Our best electric smoker ranking with both brands side by side scores them against each other, and this page shows how they split on each feature.

Which is better, an EAST OAK or a Masterbuilt electric smoker?

The Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital is the better pick for most households because it lists nearly the same space for a lower price tier. EAST OAK is better if you want the most room, a built-in meat probe and a viewing window. Neither brand fixes the common electric smoker weakness: thin smoke at low heat.

Here is the short version for the four models compared on this page, all of them 30-inch vertical electric smokers with digital controls and a side chip loader:

  • Masterbuilt 30-Inch Digital: the simple, lower-priced all-rounder.
  • Masterbuilt 710 WiFi Digital: the same cabinet with an app and a lower temperature floor.
  • EAST OAK 30-Inch with Viewing Window: a built-in probe, keep-warm mode and a window.
  • EAST OAK 30-Inch with Mobility Stand: wheels, a waist-high door and an 800W element.

How this comparison works

The facts here come from the manufacturers’ listings and the patterns in verified owner reports, the same research behind our ranked guide. Owner patterns describe what buyers report most often, not what happens in every unit.

How do the EAST OAK and Masterbuilt smokers compare on paper?

On paper the four smokers are close. The listed cooking areas sit within 15 sq in of each other, every model that lists a rack count has four racks, and the weights run from about 50 lb to about 58 lb. The real differences are in the controls, the probes and the extras around the cabinet.

Smoker Area Weight
Masterbuilt 30-inch 710 sq in About 50 lb
Masterbuilt 710 WiFi 711 sq in About 51 lb
EAST OAK window 725 sq in About 52 lb
EAST OAK stand 725 sq in About 58 lb

Price tiers separate them more than specs do. The standard Masterbuilt 30-inch sits in the under-$300 tier, the EAST OAK with a stand in the low $300s and the Masterbuilt 710 WiFi in the $300s, while the EAST OAK with a window lists between the standard Masterbuilt and the stand model. Check the current tier before you buy, because a sale can change the order.

Which smoker has more cooking space?

EAST OAK has more room on paper, but only by a small margin. Both EAST OAK models list 725 sq in, while the Masterbuilt 30-inch lists 710 sq in and the Masterbuilt 710 WiFi lists 711 sq in. That is about 2 percent more area.

Listed cooking area of the four smokers
Masterbuilt 30-inch710 sq in
Masterbuilt 710 WiFi711 sq in
EAST OAK window725 sq in
EAST OAK stand725 sq in

The listed areas differ by 15 sq in at most; capacity claims and owner reports matter more than the number.

Maker capacity claims are close too. The Masterbuilt 30-inch lists up to 7 chickens, 2 turkeys, 4 pork butts or 4 rib racks. The Masterbuilt 710 WiFi lists up to 6 chickens, 2 turkeys, 4 pork butts or 4 rib racks. The EAST OAK with a stand lists up to 6 chickens, 2 turkeys, 8 rib racks or 32 burgers.

Treat those counts as ceilings. One EAST OAK owner said a single rack holds about a 2 lb chicken, so two birds per load is more realistic than the box suggests. Another uses the window model to hold finished barbecue warm and said a couple of aggressively trimmed 15 lb briskets are about the biggest load it takes. EAST OAK window owners also complain about shelf supports that limit usable space and a fixed floor that makes cleaning harder.

Close-up of BBQ ribs with grilled vegetables and salad on a wooden table
Ribs are the load these 30-inch smokers handle best: halve the racks to fit the shelves. · Photo by Din on Pexels

Which electric smoker makes more smoke at low temperatures?

Neither brand makes much smoke at low temperatures, and that is the loudest complaint in the owner reports for both. Owners of the Masterbuilt 30-inch say it makes little smoke at 225°F and needs about 275°F to get chips going. EAST OAK owners report little smoke below roughly 250°F, and chips that blacken instead of burning.

The cause is the same in both cabinets: a heating element sets the temperature, and a chip tray must get hot enough to smolder. At 225°F the tray often stays too cool, so wood chips scorch rather than produce clean smoke. Owners of the EAST OAK with a stand describe very little smoke below 275°F, though satisfied buyers say it smokes well at higher temperatures.

Smoke first, then lower the heat

Owners get the best smoke by starting at the top of the range for the first 30-45 minutes, then dropping to the target temperature. Add small, dry wood chips every 30-45 minutes instead of one big load.

Here is how the two brands line up on smoke, based on what owners report:

Smoker Thin Best
Masterbuilt 30-inch About 275°F 275°F
EAST OAK window About 250°F Hotter settings
EAST OAK stand About 275°F 275°F

The Masterbuilt 710 WiFi lists a 100-275°F range, so it can run low for fish, jerky and gentle cooks, but owner reports on its smoke are dominated by app and electronics complaints rather than smoke volume. In practice, set your expectations at a smoke-flavored oven.

Which has better temperature control and range?

Masterbuilt has the clearer low end, while EAST OAK has the easier keep-warm trick. The Masterbuilt 30-inch tops out at 275°F, so it cannot sear or crisp skin. The Masterbuilt 710 WiFi lists 100-275°F, which opens up low-heat jobs. The EAST OAK window model switches to keep-warm mode when its timer ends.

EAST OAK does not list a full temperature range for either model, so the ceilings cannot be compared side by side. The bigger issue for both brands is accuracy. Some EAST OAK owners report temperature readings well under the display, and owners of the Masterbuilt 710 WiFi describe temperature that will not climb and phone readouts that differ from the unit.

The fix is the same for all four: put a separate thermometer on a rack and learn the offset during a seasoning run. A digital display tells you the setpoint, not always what the meat is sitting in. That habit matters more than which logo is on the door.

The EAST OAK with a stand adds an 800W element and a double-layer insulated steel body, which the maker says hold heat in cold weather. Those are maker claims, and many critical owner reports for that model describe controllers or heaters that stopped working within months.

Which has the better chip loader, door and cleanup?

Both brands use a side chip loader, so you can add wood without opening the door. That matters because every door opening drops the cabinet temperature and lets smoke out. EAST OAK says its loader gives up to six times longer smoking per load on the window model, and rates the stand model’s chip box at 4-6 hours per load. Those are maker claims.

Cleanup tilts slightly to Masterbuilt. The Masterbuilt 30-inch and 710 WiFi both have a removable water bowl and a rear grease tray that owners and the listings describe as easy to clean. EAST OAK owners complain about a fixed floor and shelf supports that make cleaning harder. The window model adds a viewing window, but owners say it fogs up.

Close-up of delicious grilled meat skewers cooking on a barbecue grill
Small cuts such as skewers and sausages cook evenly on the narrow racks of a vertical smoker. · Photo by Nothing Ahead on Pexels

Moving the smoker is where EAST OAK pulls ahead. The window model has a rear handle and wheels, and the stand model brings the door to waist height. Both EAST OAK smokers are heavier than the standard Masterbuilt, at about 52 lb and 58 lb against about 50 lb, so the wheels are useful.

Which has better probes and controls: the built-in probe or the WiFi app?

EAST OAK is the simpler choice for probes, and Masterbuilt is the only one with an app. Both EAST OAK 30-inch models list a built-in meat probe. The Masterbuilt 710 WiFi supports up to 4 probes but ships with 1, and it adds app alerts and live monitoring.

The app is the problem. Owners describe WiFi that will not connect or sync, constant alarms, and mismatched readings between phone and unit. If you want to watch a long cook from the couch, it is the only model here that offers it, but do not rely on it to catch a problem. A built-in probe with a beep alert covers most cooks.

The standard Masterbuilt 30-inch has digital time and temperature control and no app. Fewer electronics means fewer parts that can fail, though owner reports still describe control panels failing within months on the standard model.

Which one holds up better: reliability, warranty and support?

Neither holds up clearly better, and that is the most important finding. Control panels, boards and heating elements fail in owner reports for both brands. Masterbuilt owners describe control panels failing within months and doors or heat shields wearing out after a few years, with replacement parts that were slow to arrive.

EAST OAK owners report units that would not turn on, temperature boards or heating elements that stopped within months, and support that ranged from fast replacements to unreturned calls. Satisfied EAST OAK buyers praise the solid build, easy setup and responsive replacements. The Masterbuilt 710 WiFi lists a 1-year warranty, which is short for a smoker some owners say failed in year one or two.

Season it the day it arrives

Run the empty smoker for a full seasoning cycle as soon as you assemble it, while you are still inside the return window. In several owner reports for both brands, a dead controller or heater showed up within the first few cooks or months. Keep the box and receipt until it has run well for a few weeks.

Masterbuilt has the longer track record: the standard 30-inch has been on sale since 2020. That does not guarantee better reliability, but it does mean a longer owner-report history to read before you buy.

Do electric smokers make good brisket?

Electric smokers can cook brisket, but they are not the best match, because brisket wants hours of real smoke at 225-250°F and both brands make the least smoke in exactly that range. A trimmed flat fits better than a whole packer. For the best bark and smoke ring, a pellet or charcoal smoker is the better tool, as our electric smoker vs pellet smoker comparison explains.

Both brands do better with ribs, chicken, sausages, fish and pork shoulder cut into smaller pieces. Those cook at moderate heat, where thin smoke matters less and the plug-in convenience matters more. If you cook brisket weekly, weigh that before you choose an electric smoker at all.

How do you get more smoke from a Masterbuilt or EAST OAK smoker?

Four habits help any digital electric smoker give more flavor and more consistent smoke:

  1. Run the first 30-45 minutes at the top of the temperature range, then lower the setting to your target.
  2. Use small, dry wood chips and add a few every 30-45 minutes.
  3. Keep the water bowl filled on the Masterbuilts so the cabinet temperature stays steady and the food stays moist.
  4. Add a smoke tube on a lower rack for more smoke at low temperatures, as one owner does.

Do I need to soak wood chips?

No. Soaked chips spend their first minutes making steam, and that can hold the cabinet temperature down. Dry chips smolder sooner. Add a small handful rather than a packed tray so air can reach the wood and the chips do not blacken in a pile.

How often should I add chips?

Every 30-45 minutes is a good rhythm for most cooks, and most meat only takes smoke well in the first 2-3 hours. EAST OAK rates a full chip box at 4-6 hours on the stand model, but small, dry chips burn more evenly than big chunks, so a lighter reload is still better.

What wood should I use?

Hickory, apple and cherry are common picks for ribs, chicken and pork. Use chips sized for a side loader, not big chunks, and keep them dry. Match the wood to the meat: milder woods for fish and poultry, stronger woods for pork and beef.

Who should buy an EAST OAK and who should buy a Masterbuilt?

Pick by the feature you will use, not by the brand. The table below maps the common needs to a smoker.

Need Pick Why
Lowest price Masterbuilt 30-in Under $300
Most space EAST OAK 725 sq in
Built-in probe EAST OAK Both models
Phone alerts 710 WiFi 4 probes
Low-temp cooks 710 WiFi 100°F floor
Waist-high door EAST OAK stand Wheels

Choose the Masterbuilt 30-inch if you want a simple, lower-priced first electric smoker and are happy to run it hot for smoke. Choose an EAST OAK if a built-in probe, a bit more space and easy moving matter, and you accept the controller complaints. Choose the 710 WiFi only if app monitoring and a 100°F floor matter, because its app is the most criticized part.

For a full ranking with scores, price bands and owner-report summaries for every model, see the guide linked at the top of this page.

Next in this series: How to Use Wood Chips in an Electric Smoker, Step by Step

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, EAST OAK or Masterbuilt?

Neither wins on everything. EAST OAK lists a little more cooking space and a built-in meat probe. Masterbuilt sells the lower-priced standard 30-inch and the only one of the four with a WiFi app and a 100°F low setting. Both draw owner complaints about thin smoke at low temperatures and failed controllers.

Do I need to soak wood chips for a Masterbuilt electric smoker?

No. Dry chips smolder sooner, while soaked chips spend their first minutes making steam and can hold the cabinet temperature down. Add a small handful of small, dry chips every 30 to 45 minutes and follow your manual.

Does a Masterbuilt smoker use pellets or wood chips?

The Masterbuilt electric smokers here use wood chips. A plug-in element heats the cabinet, and a side loader feeds chips to a tray, so you can add wood without opening the door. Pellets belong to pellet smokers, which are a separate type of cooker.

Do electric smokers make good brisket?

They can cook it, but they are not the best match. Brisket wants hours of real smoke at 225-250°F, and owner reports say these electric smokers make little smoke below about 250°F. Trimmed flats fit better than a whole packer, and a pellet or charcoal smoker gives a better bark.

About the author: , Editor

Mason Reid edits ProteinPan's guides to smokers, grills and griddles, sous vide, meat prep and storage, and high-protein cooking. Every recommendation is built from manufacturer specifications, long-run price history and the patterns in what verified owners report after months of use, including the complaints. When a product has a known weak spot, Mason Reid says so. How we research