ProteinPan

Weber vs Char Griller: Kettle vs Kamado Charcoal Grills

Weber vs Char Griller for charcoal: the Original Kettle and Master-Touch against the AKORN kamado, compared on weight, heat range and owner-reported issues.

By November 16, 20263 min readHow we research

Hands grilling fresh vegetables on a charcoal grill
Photo by Julia M Cameron on Pexels

As an Amazon Associate, ProteinPan earns from qualifying purchases. We never accept free products or payment for placement.

Best Weber upgrade

Cooks who want a lid holder, warming rack and inserts for zone cooking on a kettle

The short answer

  • Weber suits the cook who wants a simple 22-inch kettle: the Original is about 32 lb, fits up to 13 burgers by Weber's count and sits in the low $200s.
  • Char-Griller suits the cook who smokes often: the AKORN kamado lists 200-700°F and 445 sq in, but weighs about 97 lb and owners report rust in the ash pan.
  • Every grill here has owner reports of damage or missing parts on arrival, so inspect before you assemble.
On this page

Weber vs Char Griller comes down to a simple kettle versus a smoking kamado: the 22-inch Weber kettles are light, easy to run and sit in the $200s, while the Char-Griller AKORN holds low temperatures for hours but weighs about 97 lb. In our full best charcoal grill ranking, the Weber Original is the overall pick and the AKORN is the budget kamado.

This page compares those three grills on published specifications and owner-report patterns.

Weber vs Char-Griller at a glance

Swipe sideways to see every spec →

PickSizeWeightPrice tierWhere to buy
Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-Inch
Best Weber for most cooks
22-inch kettle, up to 13 burgers per WeberAbout 32 lbLow $200s
Weber Master-Touch 22-Inch
Best Weber upgrade
22-inch kettle, up to 13 burgers per Weber, plus warming rackAbout 37 lbHigh $200s
Char-Griller AKORN 20-Inch Kamado
Best Char-Griller for smoking
20-inch kamadoAbout 97 lbHigh $300s now
Spec Weber kettles AKORN
Style Kettle Kamado
Weight 32-37 lb 97 lb
Body Enamel Insulated steel
Heat range Vent-set 200-700°F
Price tier $200s $300s

Which is better for smoking, Weber or Char-Griller?

The Char-Griller AKORN, if smoking is the point. It lists a 200-700°F range and triple-wall insulated steel that is designed to hold heat and burn less charcoal, and happy owners describe cooking for hours on little fuel. A Weber kettle can smoke too, but you manage the vents yourself.

Top view of burning charcoal briquettes in a grill
Photo by K on Pexels

Can you smoke a brisket on a regular charcoal grill?

Yes, if the grill holds 225-250°F for hours. A kettle runs indirect with the coals banked to one side but needs more fire tending than a kamado. The AKORN is built for the job, though some owners say air leaks make 225-275°F hard to hold.

What are common issues with Weber grills?

Quality control is the main one. Owners of the Original describe dents, kettles that arrive out of round, missing brackets and assembly booklets that are mostly drawings. An out-of-round bowl matters most for smoking: one owner said theirs would not hold below 300°F.

The Master-Touch adds reports of rust and enamel chips, some within months, and lids that do not fit snugly.

Trust a probe, not the lid gauge

A couple of Weber owners say the lid thermometer reads high compared with a separate probe. A leave-in probe is the cheapest way to know the real grill temperature.

Inspect before you assemble

Every grill in this comparison has owner reports of damage or missing parts on arrival. Unbox it, check the fit of the lid and the bowl, photograph any damage and keep the packaging until it is built.

What goes wrong on the AKORN?

Rust. Owners report it in the ash pan and lower body within one to six years, even with the grill covered, plus missing hardware and a cracked cast-iron grate. Cover the grill and empty the ash regularly; our guide on how to clean a charcoal grill covers the ash and bowl routine.

Is the Weber Original or the Master-Touch the better kettle?

The Original, for most cooks. Both are 22-inch kettles with a listed capacity of up to 13 burgers, but the Master-Touch sits in the high $200s against the Original’s low $200s. The difference buys a lid holder, three air vents, a warming rack and a grate that accepts inserts.

Two Master-Touch owners said to buy the cheaper kettle instead, calling the add-ons not worth it.

Man cooking on a barbecue grill outdoors, enjoying a sunny day in the backyard
Photo by Askar Abayev on Pexels

How do price and weight compare?

The Weber Original is the lightest and cheapest: about 32 lb, in the low $200s and steady all year. The Master-Touch weighs about 37 lb. The AKORN sits in the high $300s now, but has swung from the high $200s to the low $600s, so buy it on a dip.

Weight, lightest to heaviest
Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-Inch32 lb
Weber Master-Touch 22-Inch37 lb
Char-Griller AKORN 20-Inch Kamado97 lb

Should you choose Weber or Char-Griller?

Choose a Weber kettle if you cook burgers, steaks and chicken for a household, want the lightest grill and an easy ash catcher, and smoke only now and then. Choose the Char-Griller AKORN if you smoke most weekends and want a 200-700°F range and better fuel efficiency, and can live with rust risk and a 97 lb body.

  • Pick the Weber Original for the lowest price, 32 lb weight and simple cleanup.
  • Pick the Master-Touch only if you will use the lid holder, warming rack and inserts.
  • Pick the AKORN for low-and-slow smoking and high-heat searing on one grill.
Deliciously marinated ribs sizzling on a grill with fiery coals underneath
Photo by Tâm Video Editor Lý on Pexels

Best Weber for most cooks

Weber Original Kettle Premium 22-Inch

by Weber

our score

Best for: Burgers, steaks and chicken for a household, plus the occasional slow-cooked pork shoulder

Capacity9
Temp control8.5
Build & reliability8.5
Value10
Ease of use9
Size
22-inch kettle, up to 13 burgers per Weber
Weight
About 32 lb
Build
Porcelain-enameled lid and bowl, hinged grate, One-Touch ash catcher
Price tier
Low $200s
  • The 22-inch grate holds up to 13 burgers at once by Weber's count
  • Hinged grate lets you add charcoal mid-cook
  • Owner reports include dented or out-of-round kettles and missing parts on arrival
  • Assembly instructions draw repeated complaints

What owners report

Among the owner reports we reviewed, happy owners described years of use and easy ash cleanup; critical owners clustered around dents, missing brackets, unclear assembly instructions and thin-feeling metal.

Verdict: The best default for most protein-heavy cooks: proven design, low price, and big enough for a family batch. Inspect it on arrival and keep the box until you have assembled it.

Buy timing · checked Nov 21, 2026

Fair price. It is at its usual price. No need to wait unless a big sale event is close.

Best Weber upgrade

Weber Master-Touch 22-Inch

by Weber

our score

Best for: Cooks who want a lid holder, warming rack and inserts for zone cooking on a kettle

Capacity9
Temp control9
Build & reliability7.5
Value7
Ease of use9
Size
22-inch kettle, up to 13 burgers per Weber, plus warming rack
Weight
About 37 lb
Build
Porcelain-enameled lid and bowl, Gourmet BBQ System grate, 3 air vents
Price tier
High $200s
  • Gourmet BBQ System grate accepts inserts such as a wok or griddle (sold separately)
  • Tuck-Away lid holder and tool hooks keep the lid off the ground
  • Sits in the high $200s, noticeably above the Original
  • Reports of rust, enamel chips, lids that do not fit snugly and damage on arrival

What owners report

In the owner reports we analyzed, satisfied buyers liked the roominess and versatility; critical owners described damage on arrival, rust within months and accessories that felt flimsy for the price.

Verdict: Worth it only if you will use the lid holder, warming rack and inserts. If not, the Original does the same job and leaves money for a chimney starter and a probe thermometer.

Buy timing · checked Nov 21, 2026

Fair price. It is at its usual price. No need to wait unless a big sale event is close.

Best Char-Griller for smoking

Char-Griller AKORN 20-Inch Kamado

by Char-Griller

our score

Best for: Low-and-slow smoking and high-heat searing on one grill without paying ceramic prices

Capacity8
Temp control8.5
Build & reliability7
Value8.5
Ease of use7.5
Size
20-inch kamado
Cooking area
445 sq in, including warming rack
Temp range
200-700°F
Weight
About 97 lb
Build
Triple-wall insulated steel, cast iron grates, EasyDump ash pan
Price tier
High $300s now
  • 200-700°F covers smoking through pizza-oven-style searing
  • Insulated steel body is designed to hold heat and burn less charcoal
  • Ash pan and lower body rust in many owner reports, even when kept covered
  • Missing hardware and damage on arrival show up often

What owners report

Among the owner reports we reviewed, happy owners praised heat retention and fuel efficiency; critical owners described rust in the ash pan within one to six years and missing hardware.

Verdict: The way into kamado-style cooking on a budget. Buy it for the heat retention and range, cover it, and plan on checking the ash pan for rust.

Buy timing · checked Nov 21, 2026

Good time to buy. It is priced below where it usually sits, based on our price tracking.

Next in this series: How to Use a Charcoal Grill: Setup, Heat & Cooking

Frequently asked questions

What are common issues with Weber grills?

In the owner reports we reviewed, the Weber kettles draw quality-control complaints: dents, out-of-round kettles, missing brackets and unclear instructions. The Master-Touch also has rust and enamel-chip reports.

Can a charcoal grill be used as a smoker?

Yes. The Char-Griller AKORN lists 200-700°F and holds low temperatures on little charcoal. A Weber kettle can smoke with the coals banked to one side, but needs more fire tending.

Can you smoke a brisket on a regular charcoal grill?

Yes, if it holds 225-250°F for hours. A kettle runs indirect with the coals banked to one side but needs more tending; a kamado holds the range with less work, though some AKORN owners report air leaks.

About the author: , Editor

Mason Reid edits ProteinPan's guides to smokers, grills and griddles, sous vide, meat prep and storage, and high-protein cooking. Every recommendation is built from manufacturer specifications, long-run price history and the patterns in what verified owners report after months of use, including the complaints. When a product has a known weak spot, Mason Reid says so. How we research